Introduction
Columbus, Ohio, a city known for its vibrant arts scene, burgeoning tech industry, and, of course, its passionate love for the Ohio State Buckeyes, also boasts a surprisingly diverse and delicious culinary landscape. Years ago, this culinary scene was thrust into the national spotlight when the popular Travel Channel show, “Man v Food,” descended upon the city. Hosted first by Adam Richman, and later by Casey Webb, the show reveled in highlighting outrageous food challenges and the brave souls willing to tackle them. While the show itself focused on the spectacle of competitive eating, the Columbus episodes served as a delicious introduction to some of the city’s most beloved, if sometimes over-the-top, restaurants. Although some establishments that welcomed Richman and Webb have since shuttered their doors, many still stand, continuing to serve up the same delicious dishes that caught the eye of a nation.
This article takes a nostalgic trip back to “Man v Food’s” adventures in Columbus, examining the restaurants that made their mark, the challenges that tested even the most seasoned eaters, and the lasting impact the show had on the city’s food culture. We’ll explore what those featured restaurants are doing today, noting any changes to their menus or whether those famous challenges still beckon hungry patrons. Beyond the challenges, we will highlight their signature dishes. Although not all those featured on “Man v Food Columbus Ohio” are still around, let’s dive in and discover what remains of this iconic episode of television.
Thurman Cafe: A Burger Battle Royale
No discussion of “Man v Food Columbus Ohio” can begin without mentioning the legendary Thurman Cafe in German Village. A Columbus institution, Thurman Cafe is famed for its over-the-top burgers, and it was their gargantuan “Thurmanator” that caught Adam Richman’s attention.
The Thurmanator is not for the faint of heart. Stacked high with two twelve-ounce burgers, bacon, ham, sauteed mushrooms, onions, a multitude of cheeses, and a pickle, it’s a culinary Everest that even the most seasoned burger enthusiast might hesitate to climb. Adam Richman took on this massive burger with gusto, managing to devour a significant portion of it on the show. It was a valiant effort that cemented the Thurmanator’s place in “Man v Food” history and helped further solidify Thurman Cafe’s reputation as a Columbus must-visit.
Today, Thurman Cafe is as popular as ever, often with lines snaking out the door, especially during peak hours. The Thurmanator remains a fixture on the menu, still challenging brave eaters to test their limits. The restaurant has retained its quirky, no-frills atmosphere, and the walls are covered in memorabilia, including photos from the “Man v Food” episode. The appearance on “Man v Food” undeniably gave Thurman Cafe a significant boost in national recognition, drawing burger lovers from far and wide to attempt the Thurmanator challenge. The restaurant continues to benefit from this exposure, welcoming a constant stream of new customers eager to experience a piece of television history.
However, Thurman Cafe offers much more than just the Thurmanator. Their other burgers, while not quite as intimidating, are equally delicious and crafted with the same high-quality ingredients. From the classic cheeseburger to more adventurous creations like the “German Village Burger,” there’s something on the menu to satisfy every palate. The chili, onion rings, and other sides are also noteworthy and contribute to the overall Thurman Cafe experience.
Schmidt’s Sausage Haus: A Cream Puff Colossus
Next on our “Man v Food Columbus Ohio” tour, we travel to Schmidt’s Sausage Haus in German Village. While Thurman Cafe offered a burger challenge, Schmidt’s presented a sweet temptation: the Bahama Mama and the Jumbo Cream Puff.
Adam Richman didn’t just stop at the burger joint when he visited Columbus! While the Thurmanator required brute force and a strong stomach, the Schmidt’s challenge demanded a different kind of endurance. He had to devour the spicy Bahama Mama sausage and also tackle the restaurant’s famous Jumbo Cream Puff. These puffs are not to be trifled with. Each massive puff is filled with a generous helping of fresh, sweet cream. It is more than enough to satisfy a sweet tooth.
Schmidt’s Sausage Haus remains a vibrant and beloved part of the Columbus culinary scene. The restaurant still proudly serves its signature sausages and German specialties, and the Jumbo Cream Puffs continue to tempt diners. The appearance on “Man v Food” only amplified Schmidt’s already strong reputation, attracting even more visitors eager to sample their traditional German fare and indulge in the legendary cream puffs.
Beyond the Jumbo Cream Puff and Bahama Mama, Schmidt’s boasts a wide array of authentic German dishes, including bratwurst, sauerkraut, and potato salad. The restaurant’s lively atmosphere, complete with polka music and traditional German decor, creates a festive and memorable dining experience. Whether you’re craving a hearty sausage or a sweet treat, Schmidt’s Sausage Haus offers a taste of Germany right in the heart of Columbus.
Arepazo Tapas Bar: A Taste of Venezuela
While focusing on challenges and sheer volume of food, “Man v Food” also explored the diverse culinary influences present in Columbus. Arepazo Tapas Bar, offering a vibrant taste of Venezuelan cuisine, was another stop on Adam Richman’s Columbus journey. It offered a different kind of culinary experience compared to the burger and sausage challenges.
While Arepazo didn’t necessarily present a specific challenge in the same vein as the Thurmanator, Adam Richman sampled a variety of their arepas, the restaurant’s signature dish. Arepas are grilled corn cakes filled with a variety of savory ingredients, from shredded beef and black beans to cheese and avocado. These delicious corn cakes are a staple of Venezuelan cuisine and Arepazo offers a vast array of options.
Arepazo Tapas Bar has expanded since its appearance on “Man v Food,” opening multiple locations throughout Columbus. The restaurant continues to serve its authentic Venezuelan arepas and tapas, and its popularity is a testament to the quality and flavor of its food. The show helped introduce a wider audience to Venezuelan cuisine and solidified Arepazo’s position as a leading Latin American restaurant in Columbus. The exposure certainly raised awareness of this delicious cuisine, leading to increased foot traffic.
Arepazo’s menu extends beyond arepas, offering a variety of traditional Venezuelan dishes and Spanish-inspired tapas. From empanadas and plantains to paella and patatas bravas, there’s something on the menu to satisfy every craving. The restaurant’s lively atmosphere and friendly service make it a popular spot for both casual dining and special occasions. The restaurants continue to be a great option to satisfy those cravings for Latin cuisine.
Remembering Those That Are Gone
It’s important to acknowledge that not all the restaurants featured on “Man v Food Columbus Ohio” have survived the test of time. Some establishments that once thrived have unfortunately closed their doors, leaving behind fond memories but not bricks and mortar to visit.
While the reasons for closure vary, factors such as changing consumer tastes, increased competition, and the overall economic climate can all play a role. Running a restaurant is a notoriously difficult business, and even the exposure from a national television show can’t guarantee long-term success. The restaurants that are gone are still remembered fondly by many Columbus residents. Even if the building is gone, the memory remains.
When restaurants close, others often rise to take their place, and Columbus’s culinary scene continues to evolve and innovate. New restaurants and food concepts are constantly emerging, ensuring that the city remains a vibrant and exciting destination for food lovers. One of the most satisfying parts of watching these restaurants evolve is being able to continue to support local business.
Man v Food’s Enduring Legacy
The impact of “Man v Food” on Columbus’s food scene is undeniable. The show not only introduced a national audience to some of the city’s most unique and delicious restaurants but also helped to boost tourism and generate local pride. The restaurants featured on the show experienced a surge in business, and Columbus gained a reputation as a city with a thriving culinary scene.
The show also inspired other restaurants and chefs to push the boundaries of creativity and innovation. Some restaurants began offering their own food challenges, while others focused on developing unique and flavorful dishes that would appeal to a wider audience. The show helped to foster a spirit of culinary adventure in Columbus, encouraging both chefs and diners to try new things. In doing so, it encouraged restaurant owners to embrace the innovation that makes the city so unique.
The effects of the show remain today, even years after the episode aired. Many of the restaurants that were featured on “Man v Food” continue to thrive, and Columbus remains a popular destination for food lovers from all over the world. The show helped to put Columbus on the map as a culinary destination, and its legacy continues to shape the city’s food culture. Local restaurants can see increased business because of the increased awareness.
A Delicious Conclusion
“Man v Food’s” visit to Columbus, Ohio, was more than just a showcase of extreme eating. It was a celebration of the city’s diverse culinary landscape and the passionate people who create its food. While some of the featured restaurants may be gone, their memory lives on, and the remaining establishments continue to serve up the same delicious dishes that captured the hearts (and stomachs) of viewers across the country.
If you’re planning a trip to Columbus, be sure to visit the restaurants featured on “Man v Food” and experience the city’s culinary scene for yourself. Whether you’re brave enough to tackle the Thurmanator or simply looking for a delicious meal, Columbus has something to offer every palate. But take a look around, because although “Man v Food” had a great experience in Columbus, there are many other dining options throughout the city that would love your patronage as well.
So, come hungry and explore the delicious delights of Columbus, Ohio. You might just discover your new favorite restaurant or even conquer a food challenge of your own! The city is ready to make your stomach happy, so come visit and enjoy all that Columbus has to offer.
